Donations are essential to keep Write Out Loud going    

In defence of the sentimental

Rescuing George Ruby, or, Charles Dickens and the Crossing Sweeper

 

Dead, your Majesty. Dead, my lords and gentlemen. Dead, right reverends and wrong reverends of every order. Dead, men and women, born with heavenly compassion in your hearts. And dying thus around us every day. Charlie Dickens, BLEAK HOUSE, CHAPTER XLVII, ‘JO’S WILL'.

In defence of the sentimental
Dickens gave readings of 'A Christmas Carol'-
That universally known 'dream of a book' - 
To an auditorium of 2500 working class people
Then, three hours later, he did it all again. 
Dickens said:"They lost nothing
 misinterpreted nothing,
followed everything closely,
laughed and cried... “and [they]
animated me to that extent that I felt
as if we were all bodily going up into the clouds together.”
This elevated mood is condemned by some
As exaggerated and self-indulgent.
But of what? Only tenderness, sadness, or nostalgia
Even a nostalgia for a life we're still living. 
This elevated mood, whether prompted by: Jo ~
The Crossing Sweeper from 'Bleak House' or
A snippet of an Elvis song, or a bunch of lillies,
Or the photo of a loved one, all provoke a feeling
Of tenderness or sadness or nostalgia or
A cocktail of all three. Ah! but to what degree?
The pedant postulates. That decreed by the
Apparatchiks of the Woke-left, the 'enlightened'?
Nah! Don't think so. What do those sloganeers
Understand that you and I don't? Nowt. That's what. 

 

◄ The Lorelei

Saying goodbye ►

Comments

Profile image

keith jeffries

Sun 19th Dec 2021 12:52

John,
the closing lines are simply the best.
Thank you for this
Keith

Profile image

Greg Freeman

Sat 18th Dec 2021 12:54

Nothing wrong with sentimentality. Even us 'woke' 'snobs' recognise that it has a time and place. Dickens wrote A Christmas Carol to bring home the evils of mid-Victorian poverty. We could do with an updated version today.

Profile image

John Marks

Fri 17th Dec 2021 23:30

Exactly right Mark. Intellectual and social and cultural snobbery - pure and simple. By-the-way, a very happy Christmas to you and to yours. John

Profile image

M.C. Newberry

Fri 17th Dec 2021 23:17

There can be a certain snobbery towards what is often derided
as "sentimentality". It smacks of a want of humanity that I find
repugnant.

If you wish to post a comment you must login.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

Find out more Hide this message