Donations are essential to keep Write Out Loud going    

The Masterly Strategy of Inactivity (Not In My Name)

entry picture

(This is a re-post from 2013, the time the Commons decided not to take military action against al Assad.  It was feared that to do so might encourage fundamentalist groups to profit.  So that went well.)

 

You passed a man in the street

He was beating his dog

The dog was cowed; its welts bled; its back broken

You said “Someone should do something”

And you did nothing.

 

You came upon a soldier

He was raping a young girl

She pleaded and cried for her mother

Then she was silent

You said “Someone should do something”

And you did nothing.

 

You watched a group of men

They were kicking a child

He shielded his head but they stamped on his skull

As he lay on the ground

You said “Someone should do something”

And you did nothing.

 

You spoke to an old Jew who survived Auschwitz

He said to you,

“Why did you not bomb the concentration camps?

Some of us would have survived.

But you did nothing”

 

You watched an evil man, mighty in his own land,

Gas his own people.

They twisted and twitched and vomited in their death throes

You said “Someone should do something”

And this time you did do something

You wrung your hands and said,

“Someone should do something”.

 

The wreak of Bush and Blair

Hangs heavy in the air

As little men conduct analysis;

“Do nothing.  Let’s not rush.

Remember Blair and Bush”

Endorsing death by their paralysis;

Which helps Assad decide

To repeat this genocide

And brings you one step nearer to your shame;

You may give succour, quarter

“Spectating Assad’s slaughter”

Don’t ever think you do so “in my name”.

◄ THE WOOLLY TRUNKS

JOSE MOURINHO ►

Comments

Profile image

John Coopey

Mon 7th Dec 2015 23:13

I'm just re-reading "The Haj" by Leon Uris, Harry. Excellent historical fiction but also revealing about Arab psychology.
...and pluralist democracy will come when icebergs float down the River Jordan.

Profile image

Harry O'Neill

Mon 7th Dec 2015 21:36

If anyone wants to know the tasks that lie
before us over this problem, they should
carefully read Tony Blair`s (yes Tony Blair)
recent speech in Washington.

Our decision will inevitably (I.M.O.) lead to some
(hopefully United Nations) boots on the ground.
If ISIS are defeated and the populations return
the problem (given Turkey and Russia`s stance
towards Assam and the Kurds) will be who is going
to govern such a bewildering conglomeration of
different loyalties. one thing that seems very off
the table is any chance of pluralist democratic rule.

Profile image

John Coopey

Sat 5th Dec 2015 20:38

Not disputing it, Tommy. That's because the West was the last to trample there. But its footfall was was not the heaviest just the most recent. And, of course, do you believe the problems of the region owe nothing to its Arab populations?

Profile image

Tommy Carroll

Sat 5th Dec 2015 19:13

John I cover most of it

your comment below vis-a-vis historical involvement. The following: "The West are responsible for much of the turmoil in the area, especially since
WW1.".

Profile image

John Coopey

Sat 5th Dec 2015 13:57

Enlightenment No 2, Tommy. The Balfour Declaration and Sykes Picot Agreement undoubtedly contributed to the mess. But didn't the Ottomans have a benign little sojourn there for a few centuries? And haven't Muslims been killing one another since the 6th century? And didn't that nice Mr Hitler cause hundreds of thousands of surviving Jews to seek a national homeland in Palestine?
No, Tommy, your contribution as a Westerner to the cock-up is real but is only one of many.

Profile image

Tommy Carroll

Sat 5th Dec 2015 12:53

Enlightenment no1 (as requested John) Why is it the West's duty to resolve the turmoil in the region with "shock and awe". The West are responsible for much of the turmoil in the area, especially since
WW1.

*Below is a link. UK spent 13 times more post war


UK government spent 13 times more bombing than on rebuilding post war

TRIPOLI, LIBYA - AUGUST 29:
Herald Scotland:
Jody Harrison, Reporter / Sunday 26 July 2015 / News

Published Sunday 26 July 2015 /

Profile image

John Coopey

Fri 4th Dec 2015 21:38

I think the key phrases for mr in this, MC, are "tribal" and "religious dogma". The Middle East is beset with divisions too irreconcilable for the West to solve.

Profile image

M.C. Newberry

Fri 4th Dec 2015 17:55

The essence of these lines is understood. But it's always
easy to be wise with hindsight - as I will show with my
own opinion that George Bush Senior failed by not pushing
on with the guidance of his general "Storming Norman" and
seeing the job through. This failure gave his opportunistic
son Dubya the chance to return and add to the mess.
However, the tribal nature of the Middle East would have
been entirely suited to Lincoln's words about some people
and all the people. Trying to please that lot is an ongoing
puzzle that is beyond the ability of the "West" to solve...
beset as the region is by the sort of religious dogma that
makes the situation in Ireland seem like Sunday School.

Profile image

John Coopey

Fri 4th Dec 2015 17:24

The situation is indeed complex, David, although it seems it has had the effect of making experts of us all!
I am convinced that where we are today can be routed back to our failure to take action against Assad. That doesn't mean necessarily that we would be now somewhere better but we would be somewhere different, and personally I'd have rolled the dice.

Profile image

John Coopey

Fri 4th Dec 2015 17:17

Enlighten me, Tommy.

Profile image

Tommy Carroll

Fri 4th Dec 2015 13:42

I'm afraid your analogy of events regarding the middle-east John is simplistic and woefully short on analysis.

If you wish to post a comment you must login.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

Find out more Hide this message