Donations are essential to keep Write Out Loud going    

'A thistle can draw blood': Carol Ann Duffy on the Scottish independence verdict

entry picture

The poet laureate, Carol Ann Duffy, has delivered a poem on the Scottish independence referendum, a day after the 55%-45% No verdict. As the Queen issued a measured statement expressing the hope that “all of us throughout the United Kingdom” would respect the outcome of the vote, Duffy’s poem, ‘September 2014’, opens with the lines: “A thistle can draw blood, / so can a rose”.  It is published on the front page of Saturday’s Guardian. Duffy was born in the Gorbals in Glasgow, and is the first Scot to have been appointed poet laureate. Her poem concludes: “Aye, here’s to you, / cousins, sisters, brothers, / in your brave, bold, brilliant land: / the thistle jags our hearts, / take these roses / from our bloodied hands.”  

 

September 2014

 

Tha gaol agam ort *

 

A thistle can draw blood,

                                            so can a rose,

growing together

where the river flows, shared currency,

across a border it can never know:

where, somewhen, Rabbie Burns might swim,

or pilgrim Keats come walking

out of love for him.

                                  Aye, here’s to you,

cousins, sisters, brothers,

in your bold, brave, brilliant land:  

the thistle jags our hearts,

take these roses,

                             from our bloodied hands.

 

*I love you

 

 

Carol Ann Duffy

 

 

◄ Kate Tempest, Simon Armitage and Jackie Kay in big poetry lineup at Manchester lit festival

Five titles are contenders for first collection prize ►

Please consider supporting us

Donations from our supporters are essential to keep Write Out Loud going

Comments

Profile image

M.C. Newberry

Wed 24th Sep 2014 16:41

I like it. The thistle and the thorn of the
wider historical antipathy set against the
more personal evocation of the individual
attributes that emphasise what links our two lands and their human qualities to common advantage.

Profile image

Isobel

Wed 24th Sep 2014 15:01

Mmmm - the more I read it, the more I like it. I think some poems are like that. On first reading they can be very easy to discount as 'too easy' or having no value.

Now I'm struck by the pathos and the poignancy of the last few lines. The gift of giving flowers from bloodied hands. We can both hurt each other - but there is still love in the mix.

Profile image

Dominic James

Wed 24th Sep 2014 14:46

I am reminded of the Red Rose and the Briar, which is a beautiful figure, but this, bloody border? It has sense though, it sounds okay, quite good. ach.

Profile image

Isobel

Tue 23rd Sep 2014 21:25

Well I liked it. It's relevant to our times - it makes you think and I like the analogies. The whole devolution thing HAS been a painful process causing hurt on both sides of the border, a border that doesn't exist for nature, or for poets...

I think she pretty much nails that thought

Profile image

Dominic James

Tue 23rd Sep 2014 07:58

Yep. Can anyone point out any merit in this poem? I'd like to think I've missed somewhen.

Profile image

John F Keane

Mon 22nd Sep 2014 19:00

Duffy is to poetry what Tracey Emin is to art...

Cough

Profile image

Shirley-Anne Kennedy

Sat 20th Sep 2014 16:29

Absolutely *love* this!

If you wish to post a comment you must login.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

Find out more Hide this message