Gaza

History will record how lamentably we failed;

the indigestible truth that money can’t buy you

love, shelter, bandages, put bread upon

a non-existent table

without safe passage.

 

History will peel away the flesh

of all our collective anguish

the hand wringing, the tears

the howling at the moon,

focussing instead

on numbers, places, dates

the bare bones in rubble

of a once promised land...

 

History will skip over details

of how people died

the burning buildings

the turkey shoot run

of parents trying to provide

stripped first of dignity

a race against

and out of time

 

And if the victors write the history books

as Churchill once said

will those scribes

ever reflect upon the irony

of history repeating,

offer comfort in platitudes

like ‘Never Again’

as shaking our heads

and drying our eyes

we silently turn the page.

 

🌷(6)

Gaza

◄ Despair on fiscal policy

Comments

Profile image

Isobel

Fri 20th Jun 2025 13:02

Ray
I stand doubly corrected and have changed my poem to reflect it. Thank you for pointing that out! The play I read was so clever if you ever get chance to read it. It really brought to life that concept. Having any kind of original thought is so hard. As I posted the poem I wondered how many other poets might have used the same imagery, because there are only so many ways you try to describe something.

Graham

Thank you for your welcome! I don't write much poetry any more and tend to only write if I'm deeply upset about something. Gaza is like nothing else I've experienced in my considerable lifetime. Normally you can assuage your conscience by giving money to a disaster fund, but that isn't the answer here.

I find myself deeply affected by a sense of powerlessness and poetry is the only thing I can do to register that. I think during the Holocaust the man in the street didn't really know what was going on so was spared the trauma - but we get to not just know but witness the most appalling footage on TV. I don't think I'll ever forget this or lose the feeling of inadequacy.

Profile image

Ray Miller

Fri 20th Jun 2025 12:43

Yeah, I'm referring to the "History is written by the victors" phrase, too. Sartre may have used the phrase but it dates back to at least the 19th century, though most sources cite Churchill as the originator of the phrase.

Profile image

Graham Sherwood

Fri 20th Jun 2025 12:26

Izzy!!! Great to see you back but sad the subject matter is such a dire one. I’m afraid I cannot bring myself to write about this horrendous mess. Once again the bad guys screw it up for the little people etc etc!!

Lovely to have you back. Don’t be a stranger G

Profile image

Isobel

Fri 20th Jun 2025 12:23

Thanks for your comment Ray. I was referring to the fact that victors write the history books in the poem with the Sartre reference, not the Never Again phrase. I'm glad you've highlighted it as confusing though - I might tinker with the order of those words.

As a student many moons ago I read a play by Sartre 'Les Mains Sales', or dirty hands in other words. The play suggested that how we view an event historically depends on who won the war - that everything turns on that. So a Gestapo officer might have been viewed as a hero had things turned out differently and Germany was never defeated. It's a depressing thought.

Profile image

Ray Miller

Fri 20th Jun 2025 10:56

Hello Isobel. Good poem, bad times. Interesting you attribute that phrase to Sartre. The phrase, in various forms, can be traced to the 19th century, but these days it's generally attributed to Winston Churchill. Which kind of validates the proposition.

If you wish to post a comment you must login.

This site uses only functional cookies that are essential to the operation of the site. We do not use cookies related to advertising or tracking. By continuing to browse, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

Find out more Hide this message