Donations are essential to keep Write Out Loud going    

<Deleted User>

Jump to most recent response

Page Three Wannabe

I really like this poem Cayn, it is very sad - the only thing I'd say is watch your spelling (you call him a she and a he - obviously this could be part of the theme but should he not be one or the other?)
Fri, 14 Sep 2007 02:46 pm
message box arrow

<Deleted User>

Sorry honey, just spotted 'the thought enetered the head' doesn't sound right, I appreciate you are trying to disguise his gender but could you perhaps use an ambigous name i.e. Alex also we may feel more for the character if we have a name? Also watch your tenses he should own a penis not 'owned' before he has the op.
Sorry honey hope you don't think I'm being mean, I just think this is a really good poem and it would be ashame for the little things to spoil it.
Magi
xxx
Fri, 14 Sep 2007 02:51 pm
message box arrow

<Deleted User>

it's a very good poem sweet, I look forward to hearing you perform it.
xxxx
Fri, 14 Sep 2007 04:05 pm
message box arrow

<Deleted User>

In response to Sophie's comments...yes I am ace and yes I love Shelley in fact I sometimes think his penance for being such a soppy romantic is to live out his Karma trapped in my body, note I am in love with the world and love beautiful things especially men - no I'm not saying Shelley was a homosexual - though I think like me intellectually he wasn't bpthered about gender and fell in love with everyone especially his fellow poets and artists, hey ho that's another story.
Normally I wouldn't be pinnicky about tense but I think it is important for this poem as the fact the character has a penis is massively important, the fact he 'owned' a penis implies he no longer does - why then is he going for the op to have the chop?
Baby cakes Cayn, you know I love your poetry and it is only because I believe in the potential of this poem, which I really truly believe could be one of your best with a little tweeking.
all my love my homies.lol
xxxxx
Fri, 14 Sep 2007 09:16 pm
message box arrow

<Deleted User>

Hi Sophie,
Thanks for your very kind response, my proper name is Margaret yuk and then I shortened it to Maggie and then when I started to get recognised for my writing I changed the spelling for a number of reasons, 1) Its now symmetrical Magi Lane, 2) 8 is my lucky number, 3) And yes more importantly in respect of the wise (wo) men who have previously been known as Magi's, and Sages.
I am very spiritual and I believe in cosmic ordering and in going by this name I am asking the universe to provide me with wisdom (and it appears to be working as each day I grow wiser and more philosophy)
4) In connection with Magic, I am a witch in the old fashioned sense of the word as I respect mother earth and her healing abilities, I am a spiritualist and partake in hands on healing and (crystal, candle and colour therapy which come originally from Wicca traditions)
xxxx
Sat, 15 Sep 2007 03:20 pm
message box arrow

<Deleted User>

Cayn,
Nic has just pointed out that your whole poem is in past tense and your spelling mistake is simply a spacing mistake - so my corrections are bollocks mate - sorry!
xxxx
Sun, 16 Sep 2007 11:50 pm
message box arrow
I like this ..... It comes as a humourous shock to see that the character owns a penis. I saw the title and thought this will be a good read for a bit of titilation .... In fact it was a good read for a whole host of other reasons.

I am very open minded indeed but reading this poem exposed (to myself at least) my pre-conceived prejudices that the page 3 model would be a "natural" woman and the fact I laughed goes to show that, perhaps, I am not as open minded as I would like to think. I am actually disappointed in myself for this.

Some of the confusion between "he" and "she" works well and highlights the mental dilemmas that trans genger people must face on a daily basis.

It is a shame that she ends up in a hospital for people with mental illnesses, although it is understandable. I must admit, I am not keen on the ending due to the fact that it seems to be a gratuitous poke at the trans gender population, making humour out of what essentially is a predicament that people (through no fault of their own) find themselves in). It feeds prejudice (in my humble opinion).

That aside, like I said it also challenges my own prejudices and I like it.

Thanks for sharing.
Fri, 21 Sep 2007 04:37 pm
message box arrow

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

Find out more Hide this message