Language -- it's all fingers and thumbs

He’s four years old.

Have you forgotten that four-year-olds

know things which grown-ups have forgotten ?

 

But when you’re four years old

it’s difficult to explain to them

why they’re wrong..

 

let him explain as best he can :

‘A thumb isn’t a finger !’

how many more times

does he have to tell you.. ?

 

Look .... four fingers, they’re for fingery things;

and a thumb, right ? That’s for thumby things.

 

So how can a thumb also be a fifth finger ?

And then you grown-downs wonder

how your children get screwed-up.

You can’t even talk your own language.

 

You want him to grow up a reasonable person

and when he uses reason for the first time...

 

He thumbs his nose at you. A thumb is no use

for fingering bogies. That

comes after you've caught one. QED.

◄ When is a New Year ? A thought from Rochdale

A Business Trip. A sonnet for Epiphany ►

Comments

michael shepherd

Thu 31st Dec 2009 16:18

Those 'experts' who say children can't reason should be told firmly : we can reason at four years old..and we never, never forgive those who don't listen to us...

Profile image

Cynthia Buell Thomas

Thu 31st Dec 2009 15:27

I have not forgotten. I don't think anyone who is a good teacher ever forgets - such sincere relatability to childhood and youth is an essential quality to be treasured and nurtured. (P.S. I know 'relatability' is made up)

If you wish to post a comment you must login.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

Find out more Hide this message